player cards or pick'em: which one do you actually trust more
Yarik ·
ok so i keep going back and forth on this. for me pick'em feels more like a fair test of who knows the scene but player cards are just fun because you only need one guy to have a big series. idk if that makes me a casual or not?? what do people here do, one or both? and is anyone actually tracking which of the two pays off more over a season?
Mira ·
not a casual, Yarik, you're just describing two different games. pick'em rewards knowing the scene, player cards reward backing one guy's ceiling, and both are fine. I'd take the card if I want the fun, pick'em if I want to be proven right. and nobody's tracking the season split here that I can see, so the honest answer is we don't know which pays more
Tema ·
pick'em for the brain cards for the nerves. i'd hold 2 cards on the same team just to suffer together
Den ·
Nah, Tema's nerves line is the best thing in the thread, but I'd separate the two on a different axis. Pick'em is decided by a whole bracket of series, a card by one player's ceiling, so the variance is simply not the same.