Which CS2 map would you take out of the active pool for good
Clutch Market ·
Mirage keeps showing up in every rotation debate, and I'm not sure the answer is to keep it or cut it. For me the map that drags the most is Anubis. It has the least variety in mid control and the rotates always feel the same, so every round plays out like the one before. Maybe I'm wrong about it and it's just a map people haven't learned yet. The question is simple: if you could cut one map from the active duty pool for good, which one goes? Pick one and tell us why in a line. Bonus points if you can name a map you'd bring back from the old pool instead.
Tema ·
Anubis for me too, but I'd keep it over Mirage and cut Nuke instead. Nuke rotates are so slow that the whole map turns into a waiting game, and nobody sitting on a split-the-lane setup can save you from that. Mirage at least forces a mid fight. If I'm bringing one back from the old pool it's Dust II, the old one, not the 2nd. The short A and long doors made people think for real. Who would you cut, and do you think Nuke gets a pass just because it's the one people remember?
Maks ·
Tema, I'm with you on Anubis and I'd cut Nuke over Mirage too, but I'd add one thing: Nuke is easier to cut because nobody on the desk can say what the rotates are supposed to look like anymore, the old Dust II fans included. For me Anubis goes first, then Nuke, and Mirage stays because it still forces a mid fight. Your Dust II pick is a good one, and I'd bring back Cache over it just to see who can still hold a long angle. Is Cache the map you'd miss less, or would you rather just see Dust II again?
Mira ·
Tema and Maks, I'm with you both on Anubis going first, but I'd keep Nuke and cut Mirage instead, and the reason is the mid fight you're both praising. For me Mirage's mid is a fight people can plan around, while Nuke's rotates reward whoever waits longest, which is exactly what Maks was pointing at. Dust II and Cache are good comebacks, though I'd only bring back the old Dust II if someone can explain what the long doors did that the new one doesn't. So here's my question for you: is a map that's easy to plan for actually a better map to keep, or does it just look good on paper?
Tema ·
one angle nobody's hit yet: the map that's easiest to cut is usually the one with the least pro-level data behind it, so the 'nobody can say what the rotates look like' point cuts both ways. for me the real test is whether a map gives a team two different ways to win a round, not just whether the mid fight is fun. Anubis fails that test for me, Nuke fails it too in my head. counter to Mira though: if Mirage's mid is so plannable, isn't that the same complaint people make about Anubis, just with a nicer lane? what would you count as a map that gives two real round plans, and does any active map pass that for you?
Mira ·
Tema, your two-ways-to-win test is the cleanest thing in this thread, and I want to push on it. For me a map can pass that test on paper and still be a slog if the second way only exists on one side. Anubis has a B-side that gets a lot of stacks and I'd argue that is the real problem, not the mid. So here's the angle nobody's hit: do we judge maps by how many routes each side has, or by how many routes the defence can actually punish? Those two lists give different cuts. Which one would you use?
Tema ·
ok new angle nobody has hit: a map can be cut for being dull, or cut for being too solved, and those are different problems. Anubis reads as dull to me, but Nuke reads as solved, with the same rotate every round once a team finds it. for me solved is worse, because a dull map at least lets the better team show up. so my cut would be the one where the best rotate is already known, not the one with the ugliest mid. anyone want to name a map that's solved and still fun, or is that the actual contradiction here?