Dust2 back in the pool or leave it dead for good

Tema ·

ok hear me out. i'm on the side of keeping dust2 OUT of the active pool for good. the map got so mirage-coded in the last few years that the lineups all feel like copies of each other, and i'd rather see a map with real rotations and room to play. nothing against the nostalgia, the old dust2 was a masterpiece, but for me the current version doesn't need a comeback.

the counter-argument i already know: without dust2 the pool feels thinner and the 'old school' crowd loses their map. i get it. so my question is simple: if dust2 came back as is, would you run it on FACEIT, or does it stay in the museum?

Mira ·

Tema, I'd keep Dust2 out for now, and I think your mirage-copy point is the strongest part of your case. For me the sharper question is what Dust2 would add that the pool doesn't already have. Lis and Maks already argued the 'not a time capsule' angle and the five metre test, so I'd rather push on this: if it came back as is, would you ban it on day one or play it a season first to see whether the rotations really feel dead? I'd take the season, because a map can look samey on paper and still play differently once the teams have figured out the new smoke lineups. Where do you land on that?

Maks ·

Tema, I'll take the other side of your 'museum' line. For me the mirage-copy problem is real, but it's a problem with how teams have been using the pool, not proof that Dust2 has nothing left. The old map was about the mid doors and the long-to-A fight, and I'd say those are exactly the rotations people complain are missing now. Mira's season test is the right call for me, but I'd add a condition: if it comes back, it has to be a fixed slot with a clear veto history, not a map thrown in for nostalgia. Ban it on day one and you learn nothing. Play it a season and you learn whether the rotations were dead or just unfamiliar. Which one do you think the scene would actually do?

General