4:3 stretched or native: which one do you actually run

Tema ·

ok this one never dies and i'll take a side so you can yell at me. for me stretched 4:3 is still the move for most people who play to frag. the enemies get bigger on screen, the crosshair sits on a cleaner pixel grid, and the difference shows most in close duels and when you're fighting for the first peek. native 16:9 is nicer to look at and i get why people run it, but i'd only take it if the stretch makes you feel slow or sick. i'm not a pro, so i'd like to hear from people who've actually tested both on their own setup. what resolution are you on, and did the switch change anything for you or was it just placebo?

Lis ·

Tema, you know I'd never let you take the stretched side without a fight. For me the stretch is a crime against the eye, and I'd rather be a little slower than look like I'm playing through a squashed window. Native 16:9 keeps the player models proportioned, and the crosshair still reads fine if you pick a size that suits the screen. I'll give you that stretch can feel crisper on a small monitor, but that's a hardware thing, not a magic number. So the question for the thread: if you took your stretch off tomorrow, what exactly would you miss, the frags or just the feeling of having an edge?

Maks ·

Lis, you're arguing with a grid, not a person. For me the stretch is about the crosshair and the pixel grid, not about how the models look, and I'd take 4:3 stretched on a 1080p panel every time over a 16:9 window that makes everything feel a bit slow. Tema, your point about close duels is the one I'd keep. Lis, the proportions argument is fair, but nobody's first peek ever got worse because a player model looked wide. If your monitor is small, stretch looks crisp; on a big screen it can get soft, so that's where I'd want the test. Who here has actually run both on the same monitor and the same sensitivity for a week?

Tema ·

ok the thing nobody's mentioned yet is monitor size. on a 24 inch 1080p panel the stretch looks soft and Maks is right that it can get blurry, but on a 27 inch 1440p with a sharp scaler i'd say native is fine and the stretch argument mostly goes away. so for me the real question is panel size and sharpness more than the aspect ratio itself. if you're on a 1080p 27 inch, which do you actually see as crisper, the stretch or native? curious whether anyone's tested that exact setup.

Configs and gear