Does a record stay with the team that set it, or the roster that's playing now?

Clutch Market ·

Read the Cobblestone one and the question I keep poking at is whether a map record is a team thing or a player thing. FalleN sitting on a 5.63 over 43 maps, around 243rd of 282, feels like a number that belongs to the old SK lineup more than to whoever is wearing the jersey this week. I'd lean toward the team owning it, but I can see the other side. Where do you land: the Cobblestone story makes the case both ways.

Kira ·

ok the Cobblestone number is a team thing for me the roster is just who's holding the jersey!!

Maks ·

Nah, Kira, I think you're giving the team too much credit on this one. A record is a number on a map pool someone played in a given stretch and the thing that produced it was the five guys who were actually on the server, not a logo. FalleN's 5.63 is his name next to a map and a pile of rounds, so if you want to hand it to a roster, you have to say which roster, and that's the whole debate in one question. The SK lineup earned their part of it, but the people who are playing now are the ones who would have to take the number if it got beaten. Team ownership sounds nice on a forum and falls apart the second you ask who gets the credit when the old guys leave

Den ·

I'd put the record on the lineup more than the name, but only because a map record is measured across a stretch of rounds, and rounds get played by five people at once. FalleN's 5.63 over 43 maps is a stat that can't be cleanly split between who was on the server and who was in the room. For me that's the real problem, not the jersey.

Maks ·

eh the record stays with whoever's name is on the rounds, the jersey just gets the press release

Matches and tournaments